JIRA MCP Tools Comparison

Overview

This comparison analyzes three different approaches to implementing JIRA tools via Model Context Protocol (MCP):

1. AWS OpenAPI JIRA - Auto-generated from filtered Jira OpenAPI spec (AgentCore Gateway)
2. AWS JIRA Integration - AWS integration provider via AgentCore dropdown
3. CNOE Jira MCP Server - Community-built MCP server

Tool Count Summary

Implementation	Total Tools	Approach
AWS OpenAPI JIRA	44 tools	Auto-generated from OpenAPI spec (filtered to <2MB)
AWS JIRA Integration	35 tools	Pre-built AWS integration
CNOE Jira MCP Server	26 tools	Custom-built MCP server

Feature Coverage Comparison

Core Issue Operations

Feature	AWS OpenAPI	AWS Integration	CNOE MCP
Get Issue	✅ getIssue	✅ getIssue	✅ get_issue
Create Issue	✅ createIssue	✅ createIssue	✅ create_issue
Update Issue	✅ editIssue	✅ editIssue	❌
Delete Issue	✅ deleteIssue	✅ deleteIssue	✅ delete_issue
Bulk Create	✅ createIssues	❌	✅ batch_create_issues
Assign Issue	✅ assignIssue	❌	❌

Search & Query

Feature	AWS OpenAPI	AWS Integration	CNOE MCP
JQL Search	✅ searchForIssuesUsingJql	✅ SearchIssues	✅ search
JQL Search (POST)	✅ searchForIssuesUsingJqlPost	❌	❌
Search Fields	❌	❌	✅ search_fields
Project Issues	❌	❌	✅ get_project_issues
Board Issues	❌	❌	✅ get_board_issues

Comments & Attachments

Feature	AWS OpenAPI	AWS Integration	CNOE MCP
Add Comment	✅ addComment	✅ addComment	❌
Get Comments	✅ getComments	✅ getComments	❌
Update Comment	✅ updateComment	✅ updateComment	❌
Delete Comment	✅ deleteComment	✅ deleteComment	❌
Add Attachment	✅ addAttachment	✅ addAttachment	✅ upload_attachment
Get Attachments	❌	✅ getAttachmentContent	✅ get_issue_attachments
Download Attachment	❌	❌	✅ download_attachment

Agile Features (Boards & Sprints)

Feature	AWS OpenAPI	AWS Integration	CNOE MCP
Get Boards	❌	✅ GetAllBoards	✅ get_agile_boards
Get Board Info	❌	✅ getBoard	❌
Get Sprints	❌	✅ getAllSprints	✅ get_sprints_from_board
Create Sprint	❌	✅ createSprint	✅ create_sprint
Update Sprint	❌	✅ updateSprint	✅ update_sprint
Delete Sprint	❌	✅ deleteSprint	❌
Move to Sprint	❌	✅ moveIssuesToSprintAndRank	❌
Move to Backlog	❌	✅ moveIssuesToBacklog	❌

Workflow & Transitions

Feature	AWS OpenAPI	AWS Integration	CNOE MCP
Get Transitions	✅ getTransitions	✅ getTransitions	✅ get_transitions
Do Transition	✅ doTransition	✅ DoTransition	✅ transition_issue
Get Statuses	✅ getAllStatuses	✅ searchStatuses	❌

Project Management

Feature	AWS OpenAPI	AWS Integration	CNOE MCP
Get All Projects	✅ getAllProjects	✅ listProjects	❌
Get Project	✅ getProject	✅ getProject	❌
Create Project	✅ createProject	✅ createProject	❌
Update Project	✅ updateProject	✅ updateProject	❌
Delete Project	✅ deleteProject	✅ deleteProject	❌
Search Projects	✅ searchProjects	✅ searchProjects	❌

User Management

Feature	AWS OpenAPI	AWS Integration	CNOE MCP
Get Current User	✅ getCurrentUser	❌	✅ get_current_user_account_id
Find Users	✅ findUsers	✅ findUsers	❌
Create User	✅ createUser	❌	❌
Get User	✅ getUser	❌	❌
Remove User	✅ removeUser	❌	❌
Find Assignable	✅ findAssignableUsers	❌	❌
User Operations	❌	❌	✅ handle_user_operations
Get All Users	❌	✅ getAllUsers	❌

Work Tracking

Feature	AWS OpenAPI	AWS Integration	CNOE MCP
Add Worklog	✅ addWorklog	❌	✅ add_worklog
Get Worklog	✅ getIssueWorklog	❌	✅ get_worklog
Bulk Delete Worklogs	✅ bulkDeleteWorklogs	❌	❌
Get Changelogs	❌	❌	✅ batch_get_changelogs

Metadata & Configuration

Feature	AWS OpenAPI	AWS Integration	CNOE MCP
Get Fields	✅ getFields	❌	❌
Get Priorities	✅ getPriorities	✅ getPriorities	❌
Get Resolutions	✅ getResolutions	❌	❌
Get Issue Types	✅ getIssueAllTypes	✅ getIssueTypesForProject	❌
Get Server Info	✅ getServerInfo	❌	❌
Create Metadata	✅ getCreateIssueMeta	❌	❌
Create Priority	✅ createPriority	❌	❌
Create Resolution	✅ createResolution	❌	❌
Create Issue Type	✅ createIssueType	❌	❌
Create Custom Field	✅ createCustomField	❌	❌

Issue Linking

Feature	AWS OpenAPI	AWS Integration	CNOE MCP
Create Link	❌	❌	✅ create_issue_link
Remove Link	❌	❌	✅ remove_issue_link
Get Link Types	❌	❌	✅ get_link_types
Link to Epic	❌	❌	✅ link_to_epic

Labels

Feature	AWS OpenAPI	AWS Integration	CNOE MCP
Get All Labels	❌	✅ getAllLabels	❌

Key Differences

1. AWS OpenAPI JIRA (44 tools)

• Strengths:
  • Most comprehensive coverage of core JIRA operations
  • Excellent metadata and configuration management
  • Strong user management capabilities
  • Auto-generated from official OpenAPI spec ensures accuracy
• Weaknesses:
  • No Agile/Sprint features (likely filtered out for size)
  • Missing issue linking functionality
  • No attachment download capability

2. AWS JIRA Integration (35 tools)

• Strengths:
  • Best Agile/Sprint support with board management
  • Good balance of features
  • Includes sprint ranking and backlog management
  • Label management support
• Weaknesses:
  • Limited metadata operations
  • No user creation/deletion
  • Missing worklog functionality

3. CNOE Jira MCP Server (26 tools)

• Strengths:
  • Excellent issue linking capabilities
  • Unique features like batch changelog retrieval
  • Complete attachment handling (upload/download)
  • Worklog management
  • Epic linking support
• Weaknesses:
  • No project management operations
  • Limited metadata access
  • No comment management

Recommendations

• For Core JIRA Operations: AWS OpenAPI provides the most comprehensive coverage
• For Agile Teams: AWS Integration offers the best sprint and board management
• For Advanced Workflows: CNOE MCP Server has unique features like issue linking and changelog tracking
• For Automation: AWS OpenAPI's metadata access enables dynamic form building and validation

Implementation Notes

• AWS OpenAPI was filtered from >3MB to <2MB to meet AgentCore Gateway limits, which explains missing Agile features
• AWS Integration appears to be a curated subset focusing on common operations
• CNOE MCP Server seems designed for specific workflow automation use cases